Author Tools

View all 49

Mystery story generator

The mystery story generator writes complete whodunits where the clues are planted fairly and the solution clicks into place at the end. Give it a crime, a setting or a suspect, or let it set up the puzzle for you.

Updated 2026-11-10

Free with an EbookMagic account. No card needed.

A complete short story from one idea.

Fill in the form and your your story appears here.

The Missing Spoon at Ashcombe House

4 min readAges 10+

On the morning of the village show, Mrs Pell's silver judging spoon vanished from the locked display case in the church hall, and by nine o'clock everyone had decided it was the vicar.

Hattie Bryce, aged eleven, was not convinced. The vicar had a key, it was true. But the vicar also had hay fever, and the hall was full of lilies.

She walked the room slowly. The display case was locked and unscratched. Beside it, on the floor, were three tiny dots of yellow powder. Pollen, she thought, and then: no. Too bright. Mustard.

There were exactly three people at the show who had been near mustard that morning: Mr Okafor, who ran the sausage stall; Mrs Pell's nephew Dennis, who had eaten four of Mr Okafor's sausages; and Mrs Pell herself, who had judged the chutneys at eight.

Hattie found Dennis behind the marquee. His fingers were clean. Mr Okafor's were greasy but nowhere near the case. Mrs Pell, though, had a smear of yellow on her left cuff and a key to the case on a ribbon around her neck.

"You took it yourself," Hattie said, very quietly so nobody else would hear.

Mrs Pell went pink, then pale, then sat down. "It's plate," she whispered. "Not real silver. It's been plate since I sold the real one in 1987 to pay the roof. Someone from the antiques roadshow is here today, and I couldn't bear it."

Hattie thought about it. Then she found the spoon in Mrs Pell's handbag, put it on the floor behind the radiator, and loudly called everyone over to see what had fallen behind it. The roadshow man never looked twice, and the vicar got an apology and a jar of chutney.

What makes a mystery story work

  • Play fair. Every clue the detective uses to solve the case should be visible to the reader before the reveal.
  • Give at least three suspects a reason, an opportunity and a secret, even if the secret isn't the crime.
  • Plant one clue in plain sight and distract from it with something louder.
  • Let the detective be wrong once. A false solution makes the true one feel earned.
  • The solution should be surprising and inevitable at the same time. The reader should think, of course.

8 mystery story ideas to try

Paste any of these into the idea box above, or use them as a starting point of your own.

  • A locked-room death in a lighthouse during a storm, with four keepers and one key.
  • A podcast host realises the cold case she's covering was committed by one of her listeners.
  • A wedding cake is poisoned, but only the slice meant for the bride.
  • A retired detective notices her new carer is asking very specific questions about an old case.
  • A painting is stolen from a gallery, and the thief left a better forgery in its place.
  • Every guest at a murder-mystery dinner party has a real secret, and the actor playing the victim really dies.
  • A child's lost cat leads her to a house that's been empty for ten years, but has fresh milk on the step.
  • A crossword setter hides a confession in tomorrow's puzzle.

Turn your story into a book

EbookMagic expands a short story into chapters, designs the cover and exports EPUB and KDP-ready PDFs.

Start a book free

Questions people ask

Can it write a cozy mystery?
Yes. Set the mood to Cosy, mention a village, shop or hobby in the idea box, and it writes a gentle, low-violence mystery with a likeable amateur sleuth.
Can the generator create clues for a mystery game or party?
It can. Ask for a mystery with a list of suspects and clues, then use the story as the backbone for a murder-mystery party script.
Does the story always include the solution?
Yes. Every story ends with the mystery solved, and the clues that point to it are planted earlier in the story.

More ai story generator

Keep exploring