Author Tools

View all 49

Book reviews

Book reviews help readers decide what to read next and help authors reach new readers. They range from a one-line star rating on a store page to a long, thoughtful essay in a newspaper or on a blog. This guide covers where to find good book reviews, how to tell which ones to trust, and how writing your own reviews makes you a better reader.

Updated 2026-11-11

Where to find book reviews

  • Online stores: Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Apple Books and Kobo show reader ratings and reviews on every book page.
  • Reader communities: Goodreads and StoryGraph collect millions of reader reviews, shelves and ratings.
  • Newspapers and magazines: literary sections and review publications cover new releases in depth.
  • Trade reviews: Kirkus, Publishers Weekly, Booklist and Library Journal review books before publication for libraries and booksellers.
  • Blogs, BookTube, BookTok and Bookstagram: personal, genre-focused reviews from enthusiastic readers.
  • Podcasts and newsletters: curated recommendations and conversations about books.

How to read reviews critically

  • Look at the spread of ratings, not just the average.
  • Read a few three-star reviews; they're often the most balanced.
  • Check whether the reviewer reads and enjoys the genre.
  • Watch for spoilers, and for reviews about delivery or price rather than the book itself.
  • Find a few reviewers whose taste matches yours and follow them.

Why reviews matter to authors

For most authors, reviews are one of the most important factors in whether a book finds readers. Store algorithms, promotion sites and bookshops all pay attention to the number and quality of reviews, and new readers trust other readers. A short, honest review of a book you enjoyed, especially from a small or independent author, does real good. You don't need to write an essay: two or three sentences about what you liked and who would enjoy it is enough.

Writing your own reviews

Writing reviews sharpens how you read. You start to notice why a plot works, why a character feels real or why a book dragged in the middle. Keep it honest and specific, avoid spoilers, and say who you'd recommend the book to. Our guides on how to write a book review and book review examples show you how, step by step.

Common mistakes

  • Trusting the star average without reading any reviews.
  • Giving away the ending in your own reviews.
  • Reviewing the author instead of the book.
  • Leaving one-star reviews for problems like late delivery.

Leaving a review on a store or Goodreads

Most stores let you leave a star rating with or without a written review. Written reviews help readers more: mention the genre, what you enjoyed, and anything readers should know, such as content warnings or a cliffhanger ending. If you received a free copy, say so.

From reader to author

Every writer starts as a reader. When you're ready to write a book of your own, EbookMagic helps you outline, draft, design and export it.

Start your book

Questions people ask

Where can I read honest book reviews?
Reader communities like Goodreads and StoryGraph, trusted newspapers and trade publications, and individual reviewers whose taste you share.
Do book reviews help authors?
Yes. Reviews build trust with new readers and influence store algorithms and promotion opportunities.
How long should a book review be?
Anything from two sentences on a store page to several hundred words on a blog. Specific and honest matters more than long.
Can I review a book I didn't finish?
Many readers do, but say that you didn't finish and why, so others can judge whether it applies to them.
What are trade reviews?
Professional reviews written before publication for libraries and booksellers, such as Kirkus, Publishers Weekly and Booklist.

More reading guides

Keep exploring