Author Tools

View all 49

Mystery writing prompts

A mystery needs a question the reader can't stop asking. These mystery writing prompts give you the crime, the strange detail and sometimes the unlikely detective. Work out the answer before you start, then plant your clues fairly so the ending feels both surprising and inevitable.

Updated 2026-11-11

Free with an EbookMagic account. No card needed.

Prompts with a story already in them.

Fill in the form and your prompts appears here.

Locked rooms and impossible crimes

  1. A man is found dead in a room locked from the inside, holding a key to a different door.
  2. A painting vanishes from a gallery during a live television broadcast.
  3. Every guest at a country house wedding has an alibi, and every alibi is a lie.
  4. A diamond disappears from a safe that only opens with the owner's fingerprint, and he was asleep.
  5. A ship arrives in port with its whole crew present and its captain gone.
  6. A famous magician disappears during his own vanishing act, for real.
  7. Snow surrounds a cottage with only one set of footprints, leading in.
  8. A will is read aloud, and it names a beneficiary who died thirty years ago.
  9. The only witness to a murder is blind, and she's certain of what she heard.
  10. A man reports his own murder to the police, then hangs up.

Unlikely detectives

  1. A retired schoolteacher solves crimes using the gossip from her book club.
  2. A twelve-year-old who reads every true crime book in the library spots something the police missed.
  3. A hotel cleaner notices the same small clue in three different rooms.
  4. A crossword setter receives a puzzle whose answers describe a crime.
  5. A food critic realises the poison was in the one dish nobody ordered.
  6. A wedding DJ pieces together a murder from the song requests.
  7. A dog groomer notices a client's dog belongs to a man who went missing.
  8. A ghost who must solve her own murder before she can move on.
  9. A small-town vet who keeps getting animals from the same suspicious farm.
  10. A bus driver who remembers every passenger, and one who never got off.

Missing people and secrets

  1. A woman returns after ten years missing and remembers nothing, except one name.
  2. A family photo album where one person has been carefully cut out of every picture.
  3. A boy disappears from a fairground, and every ride operator tells a different story.
  4. A body is found wearing your character's coat.
  5. A mother receives a birthday card from her son, who has been missing for five years.
  6. A diary in a charity shop describes a crime in your town that was never solved.
  7. A nanny vanishes, leaving behind a suitcase with a false passport.
  8. Your grandfather's war medals turn out to belong to someone else.
  9. A podcast host realises the case she's investigating involves her own family.
  10. A village where everyone agrees to forget one night in 1989.

How to plant fair clues

  • Decide who did it, how and why before you write the first scene.
  • Show every important clue to the reader, but surround it with distractions.
  • Give at least two other characters a motive and an opportunity.
  • Let your detective make a mistake that costs them.
  • Reveal the solution through action and evidence, not just a speech.

Turn your prompt into a finished book

When a prompt grows into a story, EbookMagic helps you draft, format and design a cover for a complete ebook, ready to publish on Amazon KDP.

Start writing your book

Questions people ask

How do I start a mystery story?
Open with the crime or the strange event, or with your detective just before they're drawn in. Get the central question onto the page early.
What makes a good mystery prompt?
An impossible detail, such as footprints leading only one way, gives the reader a question they'll keep reading to answer.
What's the difference between a mystery and a thriller?
A mystery asks who did it and why. A thriller asks whether the hero will stop something terrible before it happens.
Can I get more mystery prompts?
Yes. The generator at the top of the page is set to mystery and makes ten new prompts each time.

More writing prompts

Keep exploring